Critics’ Choice Awards 2025: Will Baby Reindeer Win Best Limited Series?

Baby Reindeer, the dark comedy starring Richard Gadd, made a huge splash at last year’s Emmy Awards, sweeping up 6 awards including Outstanding Limited Series. The show is inspired by Gadd’s own experiences being stalked and provides an uncompromising look at the impact it had on him. Baby Reindeer was critically acclaimed for its willingness to tackle such difficult subject matter head on.

Now at the Critics’ Choice Awards, Baby Reindeer has a chance to continue its award show dominance. It is nominated for Best Limited Series against some stiff competition, including Starz’s adaptation of Ripley, HBO’s The Penguin, and Mr. Bates vs the Post Office.

While the show has proven very popular with critics and award voters so far, it has not been without controversy. A lawsuit has been filed against Netflix by a woman claiming to be the inspiration for the stalker character, accusing the show of defamation. Netflix maintains the series is a dramatization based on true events.

Will Lightning Strike Twice for Baby Reindeer?

Based on its success at the Emmys, Baby Reindeer has to be considered the frontrunner for Best Limited Series at the Critics’ Choice Awards. But there are other strong contenders that could pull off an upset. The Penguin features a transformative performance by Colin Farrell as the title character, which could attract votes.

While another award would further validate Baby Reindeer as one of the top shows of the year, a loss would not take away from its achievements. Sweeping the Emmys provides a level of industry recognition that every show aspires to. For a small production inspired by Gadd’s Edinburgh show, the success it has found on Netflix and the awards circuit is already far beyond expectations.

Will Baby Reindeer Win Best Limited Series at the Critics’ Choice Awards? 22bet21.com says it might, with odds of 1.167/1 or 85.70%!

Steep Competition at the Critics’ Choice Awards

Gadd himself is up for Best Actor in a Limited Series at the Critics’ Choice Awards. But the competition is steep, with Andrew Scott nominated for Ripley, and Kevin Kline for Disclaimer. Still, another individual award for Gadd would be further recognition of his brave performance bringing his own story to life.

No matter what happens at the Critics’ Choice Awards, Baby Reindeer is already a winner. Its unique voice and fearless storytelling have made it stand out in a crowded TV landscape. And the Emmys stamp of approval has cemented its place as one of the top shows of 2024. A win at the Critics’ Choice Awards would be icing on the cake, but the cake has already been baked.

Nothing is Guaranteed

While Baby Reindeer seems to have momentum on its side coming off the Emmy wins, award shows are always unpredictable. Voter tastes can be fickle and sometimes prizes are more about spreading the recognition around than strictly merit. So even as the favorite, nothing is guaranteed for Baby Reindeer. But no matter the outcome, the show has already succeeded in bringing an important issue to light and starting a broader cultural conversation.